Above the Crowd

The State of Texas Refuses to Block Municipal Broadband

March 21, 2005:

It appears that people are listening to the voices of the cities and their citizens, who are asking state legislators to say "no" to special anti-competitive provisions being asked for by incumbent carriers and MSOs.  Recent language in a Texas bill was  removed, thanks in part to a large grass roots movements in Texas.  Let’s hope it doesn’t re-emerge as an amendment on the floor. Texas joins Indiana and Illinois as key states that have voted in favor of consumers and broadband.  Let’s hope others follow suit.

The battle now moves to Colorado, where the current language is perhaps the harshest ever seen.  This proposed bill, in its original form, would prohibit a city from helping any new carrier whatsoever get started.  It’s a pure and blatant anti-competitive move.  It’s been modified slightly, but it is still one of the harshest proposals of any state, and once again created only to help the incumbent carriers by removing competition.  Consumers do not benefit from this language.

Let’s hope the state legislators in CO have the same sense as those in Texas and Indiana.


  1. Michael Parekh March 22, 2005

    Curious if to your knowledge any of the pro-municipal access groups in any of the states have used Internet telephony/VOIP as an additional benefit of, and justification for local/state government supported broadband Internet access.

    Given that much of the argument for traditional telco monopolies at the beginning of the last century had been making telephony available in rural communities, one would think that a similar approach using Internet telephony could be used for local/state funded wireless and wired broadband at the beginning of this century.

  2. Craig Hughes March 23, 2005

    Amusing that barely a day later, the Texas AG decides to sue Vonage.

  3. anselm March 23, 2005

    Way to go Bill! Blog is looking good, and you had good results with state legislature.

  4. Adina Levin March 23, 2005

    Michael, that would be logical, but the game doesn’t play completely by logic.

    The main argument that the telcos use is that muni broadband is the city competing against them. Using VOIP as the argument would make a case that ubiquitous internet will take down traditional telephone service. Legislators, who are close to the telcos, will run screaming.

    Legislators understand the benefits to their own districts — urban, rural, etc. They notice the calls and visits of their constituents, and act to protect them (hence the shortsighted “carveout” approach with the Texas House bill.

    But “disruptive technology” doesn’t mean a thing to most legislators.

  5. Frank April 7, 2005



  6. News Weblog December 22, 2005

    On the site today

    Here on News blog we’ll be looking at why polytunnels are…

  7. Tour News January 16, 2006

    Tour – Tour News, Pictures, Shows

    Latest News. European Tour News · Seniors Tour News · Challenge Tour News…

  8. Internet News: Blog Searches January 17, 2006

    500 Most Popular Searches

    The 25rd edition of the TOP500 list was officially presented today at the International Supercomputer Conference …

  9. Web Directory Blog January 28, 2006

    Web Catalog

    We introduce different sets of sites divided in groups by some unique criterias…

  10. Profile of AltaVista, One of the Oldest Search Engines On The Web

    Search Engine Features for Webmaster. ~ “Description” metatag – All provide some
    support, but AltaVista, AllTheWeb and Teoma make most use of the tag …

  11. Search Engine Journal February 17, 2006

    Search blog: Our Blog is Growing Up – And So Has Our Index

    quick blog post to point out two bad flaws. The methodology used does indeed have a selective bias, towards both: 1) search-engine pages…

  12. Search Blog February 18, 2006

    News from the Lab

    Welcome to the blog of the F-Secure Security Labs, maintained by the personnel in … This is not the first time winter Olympic games are being targeted by …

  13. Trends in Blog Searching February 19, 2006

    News: Search Results Clogged by Blogs

    With no deliberate effort, many dedicated weblog publishers are finding their blogs rank high on search results for topics that, oftentimes, they claim to …

  14. Official Google Blog: Setting trends

    Just click the “Search” link on your Search History page, or go directly to your … Search the Google Blog. – Archives -, April 2004, May 2004, June 2004 …

  15. Feature Search - Shoes February 25, 2006

    Shoes by brand

    Search For… Search shoes by brand and features. …

  16. Fashion & Beauty : Supermodels : Top Models : Fashion Designers …

    Web Wombat – the original Australian search engine … Today, Miyake is one of the world’s leading fashion designers. …


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Prove that you're a human *